Funeral directors occupy a unique space in our lives. They’re the guides we meet during our most vulnerable moments, tasked with the delicate balance of providing compassionate service while running a business. Over years of conversations with funeral industry professionals, a pattern has emerged: there are truths they wish families understood, but the timing, emotional state of grieving families, or industry conventions often prevent these conversations from happening.
This isn’t about exposing some dark underbelly of the funeral industry. Rather, it’s about empowering you with insider knowledge that can save you money, stress, and regret during an already overwhelming time. These insights come from funeral directors themselves: the information they’d share with their own families, the advice they give when the sales pressure is off, and the truths that emerge after decades in the profession.
It is highly encouraged you watch this summary video and download the pdf guide below: 50 Questions to Ask Your Funeral Director, to help better understand and utilize the content in this post.
1. You Don’t Have to Buy Anything From Us
Here’s the first truth that rarely gets stated outright: you are not obligated to purchase caskets, urns, or many other funeral goods directly from the funeral home. The Federal Trade Commission’s Funeral Rule (established in 1984 and still in effect) explicitly protects your right to provide your own funeral goods, and funeral homes cannot charge you a handling fee for using them.
Why this matters: Caskets purchased from third-party retailers can cost 50-80% less than those offered at funeral homes. An online retailer might sell the exact same casket for $800 that a funeral home prices at $3,200. Urns show similar markups. What costs $150 online might be $600 at the funeral home.
What funeral directors wish you knew: Most will readily accept caskets and urns from outside vendors if you simply ask. They can’t discourage you from doing so (it’s illegal), but they often won’t proactively mention this option. Some funeral directors privately admit they’d prefer you knew this upfront rather than discovering it later and feeling deceived.
Action step: If cost is a concern, research casket and urn prices online from retailers like Costco, Amazon, or specialty funeral goods websites before meeting with the funeral director. Delivery typically takes 2-3 days, which fits within most funeral timelines.
2. Embalming Is Almost Never Required by Law
The embalming question creates one of the most common misunderstandings in funeral planning. Many families believe embalming is legally required, but in nearly all cases, it isn’t.
The reality: Only a handful of states require embalming under very specific circumstances (usually involving extended delays or disease control), and even then, refrigeration is often an acceptable alternative. If you’re having a direct cremation (aff) or immediate burial, embalming serves no practical purpose.
What funeral directors wish you knew: Embalming is a service, not a legal requirement. It’s valuable if you’re having an open-casket viewing, especially if there’s a delay between death and the service, or if the body needs to be transported long distances. But if you’re having a closed-casket service or proceeding directly to cremation, it’s an optional expense (typically $500-$800) that you can decline.
Why the confusion exists: Some funeral directors may say embalming is “required for viewing” or “necessary for preservation,” which can sound like a legal mandate when it’s actually a house policy or a practical recommendation. The distinction matters. House policies can be negotiated, legal requirements cannot.
Action step: Ask directly: “Is embalming required by state law in this situation, or is it a service you’re recommending?” If recommended, ask what specific benefit it provides for your circumstances. If you’re planning direct cremation or immediate burial without viewing, clearly state you decline embalming.
3. The Cheapest Casket Provides the Same Service as the Most Expensive One
Walk into a casket selection room, and you’ll notice a phenomenon funeral directors call “the showroom effect.” The least expensive options are often positioned in less prominent locations, displayed less attractively, or presented in ways that suggest they’re somehow insufficient.
The uncomfortable truth: From a functional standpoint, a $600 casket and a $6,000 casket serve the exact same purpose. Both will safely contain and present the deceased. Both meet all legal requirements. The differences lie in materials, craftsmanship, and aesthetics, but not in core function.
What funeral directors wish you knew: Choosing a less expensive casket doesn’t mean you loved your family member less. It’s not disrespectful, it’s not shameful, and it doesn’t reflect poorly on the deceased or the family. Industry veterans will tell you privately that the guilt-driven upsell is one of the aspects of their job they like least, yet it happens because families often need permission to choose affordably.
The psychology at play: Grief makes us vulnerable to the idea that spending more somehow honors the deceased more. Funeral homes know this, and while most aren’t maliciously exploiting grief, their business model often depends on families making emotional rather than practical decisions.
Action step: Decide on your casket budget before entering the showroom. Remember that your loved one is beyond concerns about thread count and metal gauge. Choose based on your financial comfort, not on guilt or perceived expectations.
4. We See Family Drama at Its Absolute Worst (And It’s More Common Than You Think)
Funeral directors develop a thick skin quickly because they witness family dynamics under extreme stress. The pressure cooker of grief, combined with financial decisions, old resentments, and unclear wishes, creates explosive situations more often than you’d expect.
What funeral directors wish you knew: Family conflict during funeral planning is remarkably common. Some industry professionals estimate it occurs in 40-50% of services. You’re not uniquely dysfunctional if siblings can’t agree on burial versus cremation, if there’s conflict over religious preferences, or if money disputes emerge.
Common flashpoints they see:
- Adult children discovering their parents had different wishes than expected
- Disagreements between biological families and stepfamilies
- Conflicts over how to spend (or not spend) limited funds
- Religious or cultural differences between family members
- Exclusion disputes about who should be involved in planning
The advice they’d give: Designate one point person to make final decisions and communicate with the funeral home. Trying to achieve consensus among six adult children with different opinions is a recipe for delays, increased costs, and damaged relationships. Also, put your own wishes in writing so your family isn’t left guessing and fighting.
Action step: If you’re planning ahead, have explicit conversations with your family about your wishes and designate a specific person to ensure they’re carried out. If you’re currently navigating family conflict, consider bringing in a neutral third party (clergy, family counselor, or attorney) rather than expecting the funeral director to referee.
5. Simple Services Can Be Just as Meaningful as Elaborate Ones
The funeral industry has conditioned us to believe that the depth of our love correlates with the expense of the service. Funeral directors who’ve worked in the industry for decades tell a different story.
What they’ve observed: Some of the most meaningful, well-attended, and emotionally satisfying services they’ve facilitated have been simple, inexpensive affairs. Conversely, they’ve seen elaborate $20,000 funerals that felt hollow and impersonal.
Why simplicity works: What makes a service meaningful isn’t the cost of the flowers or the quality of the casket. It’s the personalization, the stories shared, the presence of community, and the authentic reflection of the person being honored. A simple graveside service where friends share memories can provide more healing than a formal viewing with all the traditional trappings.
What funeral directors wish you knew: They’re often more proud of helping families create heartfelt, affordable services than they are of their high-end sales. The $2,000 direct burial followed by a meaningful celebration of life at someone’s home can be more professionally satisfying than a $15,000 traditional service that felt like going through motions.
The permission you need: You don’t have to do it the way it’s “always been done.” You can have a service in a park, a celebration at someone’s favorite restaurant, a casual gathering where people wear the deceased’s favorite color instead of black. The funeral director’s job is to facilitate your vision, not to impose tradition.
Action step: Start by defining what would genuinely honor your loved one, then ask the funeral director how to make that happen rather than choosing from their standard packages and trying to fit your person into their mold.
6. Cremation Doesn’t Happen Immediately, and the Ashes Aren’t Really Ashes
Cremation has grown dramatically in popularity (now exceeding 60% in the U.S.), but persistent misconceptions remain about the process. Funeral directors find themselves repeatedly correcting misunderstandings that range from the technical to the deeply emotional.
Timing reality: Cremation rarely happens within 24 hours of death. Most states require a waiting period (typically 24-48 hours), and the paperwork (death certificates, cremation authorization forms, permits) takes time. If there’s any question about cause of death, the medical examiner may need to be involved, adding days. A realistic timeline is 3-7 days from death to receiving cremated remains.
What you’re actually receiving: The term “ashes” is a comforting euphemism. What you receive is pulverized bone fragments. The cremation process vaporizes all organic material; what remains is bone structure, which is then processed into a consistent texture. This isn’t disturbing. It’s just different from what many people imagine.
What funeral directors wish you knew: You don’t have to decide immediately what to do with cremated remains. They see families feeling pressured to choose an urn and decide on scattering or burial before they’re ready. The remains can stay in the temporary container the crematory provides until you’re emotionally ready to make that decision, whether that’s weeks or months later.
The division question: Yes, cremated remains can be divided among family members. The crematory can portion them into multiple containers. Some families find comfort in this; others find it distressing. There’s no right answer, only what feels right for your family.
Action step: If you’re considering cremation, ask your funeral director about the realistic timeline and whether you need to make immediate decisions about the remains. Give yourself permission to wait until you’re ready.
7. Pre-Planning Protects Your Family, But Prepaying Has Risks
Funeral directors universally encourage pre-planning (making decisions about your funeral arrangements in advance). However, many are more cautious about prepayment than you might expect.
The pre-planning benefit: When you plan ahead, you remove the burden of decision-making from grieving family members who may be too overwhelmed to think clearly or compare options. You ensure your preferences are known and followed. You can comparison shop without time pressure. These benefits are substantial and genuine.
The prepayment caution: Prepaid funeral plans involve giving money to a funeral home now for services rendered later, sometimes decades later. Here’s what funeral directors wish you understood about the risks:
- Portability issues: If you move or change your mind about funeral homes, transferring prepaid funds can be complicated or impossible
- Company stability: If the funeral home closes or is sold, your funds may be tied up in complex legal situations
- Inflation gaps: Some prepaid plans don’t keep pace with actual cost increases, leaving your family with unexpected bills
- Loss of flexibility: Your preferences may change over time, but modifying prepaid plans often involves penalties
The alternative many prefer: Instead of prepaying the funeral home directly, consider setting aside funds in a payable-on-death (POD) bank account or a funeral trust specifically designated for funeral expenses. Your family gets the money immediately upon your death, can use it at any funeral home, and you maintain control of funds during your lifetime.
What funeral directors privately recommend: Pre-plan everything, document your wishes thoroughly, but think carefully before prepaying. If you do prepay, ensure the contract is clear about refund policies, transferability, and what happens if the funeral home changes ownership.
Action step: If you’re considering prepayment, get everything in writing, understand the cancellation and transfer policies, and consider whether a designated savings account might serve you better.
8. We Can Usually Tell When Someone Died Alone (And It Matters)
This is perhaps the most emotionally charged insight funeral directors share privately: they can often sense, without being told, when someone died alone or isolated. And they wish more people understood what a difference community makes, both before and after death.
What they observe: When someone who lived connected to family and community dies, the funeral planning process typically involves multiple people sharing memories, bringing photos, disagreeing (lovingly or otherwise) about details. When someone died isolated, it’s often a single distant relative or appointed agent making perfunctory decisions, little personal information available, small or no services planned.
Why it matters: This isn’t about judgment. It’s about prevention. Funeral directors see the tangible consequences of isolation: services where almost no one attends, families who realize too late they knew nothing about their loved one’s wishes or life, and the profound sadness of lives that seemingly left no ripples.
What funeral directors wish you knew: If you’re alive and reading this, you have time to prevent this outcome for yourself. Maintain connections, even when it’s hard. Document your life, not for ego, but so people know who you were. Designate someone who knows your wishes. Participate in community, in whatever form works for you.
The practical side: They also wish families understood that when someone dies alone and isn’t discovered quickly, it creates complications (both practical and legal) that make an already difficult situation harder. Checking in on isolated elderly relatives or neighbors isn’t just kindness; it can prevent traumatic discoveries and complicated death investigations.
Action step: If you know someone who’s increasingly isolated, reaching out matters more than you realize. If you’re feeling isolated yourself, reconnect with one person this week. And have at least one person who checks on you regularly. It matters both in life and in death.
9. The Best Gift You Can Give Your Family Is Clear, Written Instructions
If funeral directors could mandate one thing for every person, it would be this: write down your wishes and tell someone where to find them. The amount of unnecessary stress, conflict, and expense that could be prevented with this simple step is staggering.
What they see repeatedly: Families in crisis, trying to guess what their loved one would have wanted, sometimes making expensive decisions out of guilt or choosing options that the deceased would have hated. Siblings fighting because no one actually knows what Mom wanted. Expensive mistakes that could have been prevented with a simple conversation.
What needs to be documented:
- Burial versus cremation preference and why
- Specific wishes about service type (religious, secular, celebration of life, none)
- Budget expectations (be explicit about whether you want simplicity or tradition)
- Location preferences if you have them
- Organ and tissue donation decisions
- Specific items you want included (music, readings, photos, personal touches)
- Who you want making decisions if you can’t
Where to keep it: Not in a safe deposit box that can’t be accessed immediately. Not only in a will that might not be read for weeks. Tell your designated decision-maker where this document is. Many people keep it with their important papers, give copies to adult children, or leave it with their attorney with instructions to share immediately upon death.
What funeral directors wish you knew: These conversations feel awkward and can be emotional, but they’re a profound act of love. You’re removing burden from your family during their most difficult moments. You’re preventing conflict. You’re ensuring your preferences guide decisions rather than guilt or guesswork.
The conversation starter: “I’ve been thinking about end-of-life plans, and I want you to know my wishes so you’re not guessing later.” Then actually have the conversation. Write it down. Update it as your preferences change.
Action step: Set a date this month to write down your preferences. It doesn’t have to be a legal document. A clear, dated letter outlining your wishes is sufficient. Share it with the person you’ve designated to make decisions.
FAQ
Yes. Funeral homes are businesses, and many costs are negotiable, especially professional service fees and package deals. The itemized pricing they’re required to provide (General Price List) is your negotiation tool. Don’t be afraid to ask, “Is there flexibility on this?” or “What can we remove to lower the cost?” Many funeral directors will work with families facing financial hardship.
A funeral home provides comprehensive services including body preparation, arrangement coordination, facilities for viewings/services, and administrative tasks. A crematory is the facility that performs the actual cremation. Many funeral homes have crematories on-site, but some contract with third-party crematories. You can often work directly with a crematory for direct cremation, bypassing funeral home markups entirely (potential savings of $1,000-$2,000).
You typically have 3-7 days before decisions become urgent, longer if the body is refrigerated or embalmed. Don’t let anyone pressure you into same-day decisions. It’s completely acceptable to say, “I need 24 hours to think about this and discuss with family.” Most states don’t require immediate action unless there are unusual circumstances.
In most states, yes. Family members can legally transport a deceased loved one, though specific regulations vary by state. Some states require a permit or death certificate first. This option is sometimes called “family-directed” or “home funeral” and can save significant money. Check your state’s specific laws, and understand that you’ll need a suitable vehicle and assistance (bodies are heavy and require careful handling).
Several options exist: (1) Direct cremation is the most affordable choice ($600-$2,000), (2) County/state indigent burial programs provide basic services, (3) Many funeral homes offer payment plans, (4) Nonprofit organizations sometimes provide assistance, (5) Crowdfunding through platforms like GoFundMe has become common and effective. Also ask the funeral home directly about their financial assistance programs. Many have funds specifically for families in need but don’t advertise them.
Not entirely free, but veterans receive significant benefits: free burial in a national cemetery (for veteran and spouse), free grave marker or headstone, free opening/closing of the grave, and a burial flag. However, the funeral service, casket/urn, transportation, and other costs are still the family’s responsibility. Veterans can receive a burial allowance ($796-$2,000 depending on circumstances) to offset these costs. Contact the VA or a veterans service organization for specific benefits.
No. Federal law prohibits scattering ashes within three nautical miles of shore without a permit. On private property, you need owner permission. National parks have specific permits and restrictions. State and local laws vary widely. Some places explicitly prohibit scattering (Disneyland gets this request constantly and always says no). Many places are legal with permission: private land, designated scattering gardens, most areas of the ocean beyond three miles. Always research specific locations before scattering.
Generally no, though they can refuse service in extreme circumstances (threatening behavior, attempting fraud, etc.). Asking questions, price shopping, bringing your own casket, declining recommended services, or negotiating prices are all completely legitimate actions that a reputable funeral home will accommodate professionally. If a funeral home makes you feel uncomfortable for asserting your consumer rights, it’s a red flag. You can always choose a different provider.
Green burial minimizes environmental impact: no embalming (or only non-toxic fluids), biodegradable casket (or shroud), natural decomposition without a concrete vault. The body is buried in a natural setting where decomposition enriches the soil. Costs are typically lower ($2,000-$4,000 total) than traditional burial. Not all cemeteries allow green burial. Dedicated natural burial grounds exist but aren’t available everywhere. It’s legal in all states but check local cemetery regulations.
Contact your state’s funeral regulatory board (usually under the state licensing board). File a complaint with the FTC if you believe they violated the Funeral Rule. Organizations like the Funeral Consumers Alliance provide advocacy and guidance. Document everything: get itemized price lists, keep all contracts, save emails and communications. Common violations include refusing to provide price lists, charging handling fees for caskets you supply, misrepresenting legal requirements, or making unauthorized substitutions.
The Bottom Line
Funeral directors enter the profession for noble reasons: to help people during life’s most difficult transitions. Most are genuinely compassionate, skilled professionals doing important work. But they operate within an industry with financial pressures, traditional conventions, and situations where being completely forthcoming might seem inappropriate in the moment.
Understanding these insider perspectives empowers you to ask better questions, make informed decisions, and advocate for what you really want. It means your family won’t overspend out of guilt, won’t agree to unnecessary services, and won’t make decisions they later regret.
The funeral is for the living. It should provide comfort, closure, and community, not financial stress or lingering questions about whether you made the right choices. With this knowledge, you’re better equipped to create the meaningful farewell your loved one deserves, at a cost that doesn’t burden your family.
The most important takeaway? Ask questions. Be informed. Remember that this is your choice, your family, and your decision. A good funeral director will welcome your informed participation and appreciate working with families who know what they want and why.
Author
-
Founder, Memorial Merits
U.S. Navy Service MemberGabriel created Memorial Merits after experiencing funeral industry complexities & exploitation firsthand when his father passed away unexpectedly in 2019.
His mission: protect families from predatory practices and provide clear guidance during impossible times.EXPERTISE:
• Personal experience with loss
• Funeral planning (multiple times)
• AI grief support development
• Published author (legacy planning)
Leave a Reply